TikTok’s Blackout: What Happens to the Community That Made Dostoyevsky Cool Again?


Unhustled Archives

Hello Reader,

TikTok is probably going dark in the next several hours, but BookTok’s light is harder to extinguish.

As I write on this Saturday morning, the platform that revolutionized how millions discover and discuss books expects to be offline in the U.S. in just a few hours.

I haven't spent much time on TikTok. Every now and then I check up on kerri_okie and her mom—they're absolutely delightful. 😎

Plus, I have a BFF who sends me screen recordings of posts I really need to see. 😁

Still, the TikTok ban got me thinking about something bigger: how we find our way back to reading what we truly love.

The Numbers Don't Lie (But They Don't Tell the Whole Story)

With over 200 billion views, BookTok has launched careers (remember Rebecca Yarros’s Fourth Wing?), turned classics into bestsellers (White Nights, anyone?), and made reading feel fresh, fun, and—dare I say it—cool.

But the real magic of BookTok isn’t the numbers. It’s the way it brought readers together to embrace what they genuinely love. BookTok proved there’s a corner of the internet for every reader, from swoon-worthy romances to Dostoevsky debates.

Finding Your "Throat-Grab" Moments

I stumbled across a YouTube video by Robert Waldun exploring attunement—a visceral feeling when a book grabs you by the throat and won't let go.

You know the feeling—when you're flying through pages almost against your will, when the rest of the world fades away, and you couldn't care less about what anyone else thinks of your reading choice.

That's what we're losing sight of when we even subconsciously build our reading habits around what a hustle culture influencer or productivity guru says are "must reads."

In our rush to read the "right" books, we're losing that pure, unexplainable connection that makes reading magical. So we learn to dread reading.

And when we do sit down with what someone else says is a transformational book, and we don't get it? We start to doubt our own judgment.

Why This Matters Now

Whether BookTok survives or not (with the money involved, someone will figure something out), its spirit reminds us of something crucial—reading doesn't need validation from algorithms or literary critics.

Sometimes, the "best" book is simply the one that makes you forget to check your phone.

What I'm Learning to Trust

By owning my current obsession with Robert Crais' Elvis Cole/Joe Pike mystery thriller series (I finished 2 more titles this week!), I'm learning to trust my judgment in other areas. And it feels good!

So in trusting your reading instincts, you're learning to trust yourself in life's bigger moments, too.

Who Are Your Book People?

Are you part of any online bookish communities?

Whether it's BookTok, Bookstagram, BookTube, or a group chat with friends, I'd love to hear where you find your reading inspiration.

Hit reply and let me know!


Read something today that delights you, Reader.

— Tracy

If you're enjoying Unhustled Reading, you might also like:

Image for Presently Reading Book Club

Presently Reading Book Club

hosted by Maneetpaul Singh

Read a new nonfiction book with me and 2,000+ others every month.

P. O. Box 224, Lavaca, Arkansas 72941
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Unhustled Books

This isn’t BookTok. It’s not productivity porn. It’s just one reader—thinking out loud about what stories do to us. Unhustled is where you go when you want the reading part of your life to feel like yours again.

Read more from Unhustled Books

Hey Reader, Ever notice how old highlights don’t always hold up? Every morning, an app I've used for several years drops a handful of my long-forgotten Kindle highlights into my inbox. If you’ve never used it, Readwise is basically a little robot librarian that resurfaces quotes you saved years ago — and allows you to talk to your highlights to glean the collective insight. Learn more about Readwise here (and get an extra 30 days if you subscribe using this link). Most of the 3 or 4...

Hey Reader, Most people blame distraction for why they stop reading. I blamed myself. I thought I was lazy. Undisciplined. Too slow to keep up with all the "smart" people online and the stacks of business books they tore through every week. Eventually my own stacks of "must-reads" felt as heavy as the guilt of not keeping up with the people I wanted to model in the world of writing and teaching online. One day I realized I hadn't read a novel in months. Since first grade I've loved fiction....

Hey Reader, I have a secret for when reading starts to feel like work again. I'm bananas over the Savannah Bananas' arch rival, the Party Animals. Yeah, yeah. What does baseball have to do with books? Stay with me. Last week I ugly-cried over the Savannah Bananas' season recap, and the new teams coming into the league next season. Not because of the baseball, but because of what I saw in the video recap: 2.2 million people choosing joy over cynicism. Fans singing Yellow with their phone...